Full UK border closure 'considered'
January 22, 2021. The full closure of the UK's borders has been "considered" by the government amid concerns about new COVID variants being imported from abroad, a minister has revealed.
Sky News' Greg Heffer reported that this week that the government has closed all UK travel corridors - which had allowed arrivals from some countries to avoid having to quarantine - until at least 15 February. People coming to the UK from abroad also now have to show proof of a negative COVID test from up to 72 hours before their journey. But Prime Minister Boris Johnson is reportedly under pressure from some members of his cabinet to go further and close Britain's borders completely to foreigners.
Environment Secretary George Eustice told Sky News that "everything is always kept under review" when asked if a full border shutdown could be introduced. "We always keep things under review and it's been considered," he said. "There is concern at the moment at number of mutant strains that there are - different strains of this coronavirus are cropping up in other countries. There are concerns that there is a risk that one day there will be a strain that might be able to evade the vaccine.
"That's why last week the prime minister toughened up the current restrictions. We require a test before people travel and then they must quarantine while they're here.
"There are now no exemptions from that policy, so we've already toughened it up - we think that's the right approach for now but, obviously, everything is always kept under review."
The prime minister was this week accused of having "overruled" Home Secretary Priti Patel at the start of the pandemic last March by keeping the UK's borders open to foreign travellers. According to The Daily Telegraph, some senior cabinet ministers are now once again pushing to close Britain's borders and copy the tough travel measures in place in countries such as Australia and New Zealand. Asked if he was among those wanting to see the UK's borders closed, Mr Eustice told Sky News: "Personally I wouldn't like to see all borders closed.
"I'd like us to get past this pandemic and get the vaccine rolled out and be able to start opening things again rather than closing things. But we can't rule anything out but, for now, the restrictions we have in place - with that requirement for quarantine and the requirement for a pre-travel test - we think that is sufficient and the right and appropriate measure for now."
At a Downing Street briefing on Thursday, Ms Patel said the UK currently had "stringent measures" at borders "for a very good reason. We want to protect the health of members of the public and we want to make sure we can deliver and safeguard this world-leading vaccine roll-out," she said.
© Greg Heffer / Sky news
The Independent's Simon Calder also reports:
As two more African countries are added to the UK’s flight ban list, ministers are contemplating introducing tough travel restrictions – of the kind that have been in force since last March in Asia and Australasia.
These are the key questions and answers.
How many countries are now included in the UK’s “travel ban”?
Twenty-nine. But the so-called travel ban, aimed at limiting the spread of new variants of coronavirus, does not ban travel from the countries on the list.
Direct flights are not allowed. For the vast majority of locations, this is irrelevant since there were no scheduled services operating anyway. Some additional restrictions apply to passengers on connecting flights to the UK: British and Irish citizens, as well as third-country nationals with residential rights in the UK, can come in whenever they like but must self-isolate along with their households for 10 days.
Other travellers cannot arrive in the UK if they have been in any of the “banned” countries within the past 10 days.
Tanzania and Democratic Congo are now on the list, joining nine other mainland African nations: South Africa, Namibia, Zimbabwe, Botswana, Eswatini, Zambia, Malawi, Lesotho, Mozambique and Angola.
The transport secretary, Grant Shapps, tweeted: “To help to stop the spread of the Covid-19 variant identified in South Africa, we are banning all arrivals from Tanzania and Democratic Republic of Congo from 4am.”
The addition of these two nations will make no significant difference; the last scheduled flights from either country, a British Airways link from Dar es Salaam to London, ended eight years ago.
Flights from three island nations off the coast of Africa – Cape Verde, Mauritius and the Seychelles – have been banned. In normal times they are popular holiday destinations with direct flights from the UK.
The entire continent of South America, as well as Panama, is on the list – adding 15 more countries.
The most significant nation, though, in terms of British visitors and expatriates, is Portugal. At present it is the only European country subject to a flight ban.
What new restrictions could there be?
“We are continuing to monitor Covid-19 rates and new strains of the virus across the globe, this alongside the suspension of travel corridors and pre-departure testing will help protect our borders,” said Mr Shapps.
From Monday this week, the UK insists on all arrivals presenting a negative test for coronavirus that has been taken within three days of departure (or longer if an en route stop is involved). Quarantine is also mandatory for all overseas arrivals except for those from Ireland. But ministers are considering much tougher and wide-ranging rules for arriving passengers in a bid to limit the spread of new variants of coronavirus – including arrivals self-isolating in designated hotels, rather than at home.
A brief history of quarantine
Early in 2020, the UK imposed quarantine measures aimed at preventing the spread of the virus from known hotspots including China, Iran and northern Italy. On 13 March 2020 these measures ended. The government said there was no point in continuing to insist on self-isolation because coronavirus was widespread in the UK.
Two days later, Australia’s prime minister, Scott Morrison, imposed two weeks of self-isolation on arrivals from all countries. By the end of March, the law had been strengthened to make “hotel quarantine” mandatory.
Three months later, on 8 June 2020, the UK government made a U-turn, going from no quarantine to quarantine from everywhere, with 14 days of self-isolation required.
A month after that, the concept of “travel corridors” took effect, allowing journeys from most European countries without self-isolation. But by late July Spain had lost exemption, and in the months since then most popular destinations have also had quarantine-free status removed.
In December, the time required for quarantine was reduced from 14 to 10 days, and in England “test to release” was brought in – allowing self-isolation to be halved for those who received a negative test result on day five.
On 18 January 2021, all quarantine exemptions were removed.
How does the system work for arrivals?
At present anyone arriving in the UK is free to take public transport home and stay there for 10 days (which can be reduced in England with a test taken after five days). If necessary, they can stay somewhere overnight on the way to their quarantine location.
Hotels are provided for arrivals from abroad who do not have a household with whom they can self-isolate, but there is no significant supervision.
Of the 12 million arrivals to England since June 2020, 3 per cent (about 400,000) have been checked upon by public health staff to ensure they are quarantining, Mr Shapps has said. The transport secretary added that checks are being increased.
How would “hotel quarantine” work?
Australia, New Zealand and many Asian nations have imposed hotel quarantine since March 2020. The standard arrangement is for the traveller to be escorted from the airport terminal to a nearby hotel.
They have a number of conditions imposed, usually stipulating that they are not allowed to leave their room – though in some cases limited exercise opportunities are available at specific times.
Meals are delivered to the hotel room. In some cases, alcohol is available, but in many settings it is not.
Security guards are often deployed to try to ensure that quarantinees comply with the rules, and in some destinations hefty fines are levied for those caught breaking them.
Cambodia has a particularly intriguing variation on the theme, with mandatory testing on touchdown. All arrivals must pay US$30 (£22) for an overnight stay at hotel or waiting centre and the same again for three meals a day while waiting for test result.
“If one passenger tests positive for Covid-19, all those on the same flight will be quarantined for 14 days,” says the Foreign Office.
The cost is US$1,176 (£863) to pay for the stay in a hotel or quarantine facility – but this includes meals, laundry, sanitary services, doctors and security services.
Could it work in the UK?
Currently hotel quarantine certainly could. The swathe of restrictions, from a ban on leisure travel for all UK residents to the blanket quarantine requirement, means that almost nobody is travelling at present.
Total daily arrivals to the UK are down from tens of thousands at the start of the year to a few thousand. Heathrow, the main access point to the UK, is surrounded by hotels, almost all of which are near-empty or closed due to lack of custom.
Other airports also have plenty of hotel capacity, with occupancy typically down to single-figure percentages.
Who would pay?
The traveller. A rough estimate of the cost is around £1,000 for 10 days in self isolation. For couples together it might be slightly less, for single travellers slightly more. The test-to-release scheme, which reduces quarantine in England, is likely to be suspended just weeks after it was introduced.
Any other measures?
Yes. Ministers are also considering tracking the phones of arriving travellers, to ensure they are complying with the rules, or establishing a system of daily registration with a central data base.
© Simon Calder / The Independent